Canberra's Mountain Biking community network

SS or geared for a recreational mtb noob?

Hi all

I'm in market for a new mtb. I've pretty much narrowed it down a Trek 29er HT, at moment I'm looking at the Trek X-Caliber. It's basically the one that meets my needs and is bang on my budget limit of $2K. I plan to use it primarily (if not exclusively) for the occasional recreational riding out at Stromlo, Majura etc. Opting for less technical, but flowing trails.

However, what got me thinking was that I currently commute with a Giant singlespeed which sees some basic climbing up Theodore hill and surrounds (fwiw, the gear ratio is 2.25 and so far seems a good compromise.) There is also a Trek "Rig" which is a singlespeed version of the aforementioned Trek 29er HT line of bikes. Should I seriously be considering this bike as an alternative? I do prefer simplicity and would prefer singlespeed over gears. BUT I have zero experience with SS mtb-ing. The ratio of the Rig is 1.8 (which I know can be easily be changed). I guess what I'm really asking is; does ACT's trails offer a recreational rider much joy with a SS? Or, is SS better placed in a race environment and should I just behave and go geared?

cheers

Brett

...........as an aside; here are some photos I took of the recent event out at Stromlo

SRAM Singletrack Mind Series - Round III

0 members like this

▶ Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Brettski on January 8, 2012 at 11:31

time for an update:

about 2 months ago, I picked up a 2nd hand (and relatively unused) 2011 Trek Rig. The gear ratio was the stock: 32/18 (gr= 1.8). I tried it at Kowen and pumped with enthusiasm for my new purchase, I got through the ride. Two things were clear after that; it was very enjoyable, the 29er wheels rolled over everything, but on reflection it was hard work. I soon after changed to 32/20 (gr=1.6) and its a far better compromise for me. In reality I'm not a fast rider so it was all about getting the best gear ratio for climbing. I have updated the chain to a pure half-link and it's a fantastic, solid and quiet ride. I have used it on about 8 rides now; at Kowen, Sparrows and Stromlo and it's my preferred bike over my excellent dually.

my take away message for new riders reading this thread is don't disregard a SS 29er, and if simplicity appeals to you, give it strong consideration!